System operators appoint independent market monitors to evaluate performance

Independent market monitors continuously assess US market performance, flag inefficiencies and market power, and recommend rule changes.

About this good practice

All seven major US regional transmission organisations (RTOs) have a market-monitoring function – some, but not all, appoint an external independent firm to provide this. For example, ERCOT, MISO, NYISO and ISO-NE have appointed Potomac Economics, a specialist firm separate from both the system operator and the regulator, as their external independent market monitor. The monitor continuously evaluates market and transmission-service performance, flags inefficiencies and attempts to exercise market power, and recommends fixes. It is a model of ongoing, arm’s-length third-party oversight that complements the regulator.

The monitor’s value comes from deep technical capability. Potomac Economics combines detailed knowledge of nodal markets and their software, RTO reliability requirements and operating procedures, and market design trends across several RTOs. It runs a proprietary monitoring system that receives, stores, screens and analyses market data, builds indices and economic models to test for withholding strategies, and produces automated reports on market outcomes and behaviour. It has also developed production-grade software that RTOs use to apply real-time market power mitigation.

Monitors also shape market design itself. Potomac argues that capacity should be valued according to its marginal contribution to reliability, because the hours of greatest need shift as resources are added. In its illustrative example, the marginal value of solar falls from 44 percent at low penetration (1 GW) to 8 percent at high penetration (20 GW), as critical hours move to the evening. Awarding resources inflated capacity values would raise consumer costs and weaken incentives for the resources the system needs. Monitoring therefore extends from policing conduct to improving rules.

Read more about the Good Practice

Want to learn more about this best practice? Follow the link below.