Incentive regulation with total-cost benchmarking

Germany caps network revenues for five years using total-cost benchmarking, and is considering a fixed capex/opex share to remove a bias towards building.

About this good practice

The Bundesnetzagentur (Federal Grid Agency) sets each network operator’s revenue cap for a five-year regulatory period. The starting point is an examination of each operator’s actual costs, based on its financial statements for the last full “base year”, which means caps rest on two-year-old cost data. Because network operators face no competition, efficiency is scored by benchmarking all operators against each other on their total costs, giving equal weight to capital and operating costs. Distribution operators are compared using structural parameters such as exit and metering points, line length, peak load and area served. The resulting efficiency level is applied to the controllable costs, and operators are required to gradually reduce only the inefficient share, keeping part of the savings they achieve against the cap.

Beyond this core mechanism, the regulator sets a return on capital for each period, allows the cap to be adjusted for expansion investments, balances volume forecast errors through a regulatory account, and adds a quality element that rewards or penalises electricity operators based on network reliability.

Since 2024 the regulator has been working on a reform. One option is having fixed shares of CAPEX and OPEX, intended to stop operators favouring capital spending over operational solutions such as flexibility. These reform options are still under discussion.

Read more about the good practice

Want to learn more about this best practice? Follow the links below.