Why this recommendation matters
The transition to a modernised grid generates new opportunities. Households and businesses can earn from generating and storing electricity and offering flexibility to the grid. Communities can own assets and receive revenue from hosting infrastructure. Regions gain skilled local employment from the infrastructure buildout and new services. These benefits carry weight beyond their economics, since sharing them broadly strengthens the public support and social licence on which grid modernisation depends.
Without active steering, the benefits tend to concentrate. Support schemes flow disproportionately to higher-income early adopters with the capital, ownership status and information to act first. Energy communities can form disproportionately in affluent neighbourhoods, where they have the effect of lowering members’ bills, while fixed grid costs can be shifted to those not able to participate in flexibility programmes. Programme rollouts often reach well-served areas first, and sometimes fully miss underserved areas.
Available benefits can go untaken where the information barrier is high, particularly among lower-income and less-resourced consumers. These concentrations are self-reinforcing, since early beneficiaries become a constituency for arrangements as they stand.
The policy task is to open participation deliberately. Support schemes can be designed to counteract regressive effects. Energy community frameworks can build inclusion in through finance provision, membership rules and partnerships with municipalities and social housing. Benefit-sharing can give hosting communities a fair share of the value they enable. Rules for financial participation in new infrastructure projects can further extend ownership. The reach of programmes can be tracked, with design adjusted where gaps appear. Sharing the value that grid modernisation creates can be an important policy goal in and of itself, rewarding the households, businesses and communities whose cooperation the transition relies on. Done well, it also strengthens social licence.
How to act on this recommendation
Stage 1
Establish participation schemes.
Design support schemes for electrification and flexibility-capable equipment such that they counteract regressive effects, through income-based support, point-of-sale subsidy provision, inclusion of used equipment and dedicated programmes for social housing. Establish enabling frameworks for energy communities, supported by clear legal definitions, simplified procedures, finance and advice, and with protections built in against elite capture.
Stage 2
Share the value and track reach.
Require projects to incorporate benefit-sharing for the communities hosting grid and electrification infrastructure, with national frameworks setting the expectations within which developers have to deliver and benefits channelled through collectively governed vehicles rather than individual payments to ensure everyone is able to participate. Enable inclusive financial participation in the ownership of transition assets through participation offers to residents and municipalities and community investment schemes. Ensure that modernisation and electrification programmes reach all customers, with inclusion targets established, uptake tracked and design adjusted where gaps persist.
Core measures
Implementation considerations
Participation schemes tend to concentrate benefits among the affluent unless deliberately designed otherwise. Energy communities can be captured by the well-resourced, shifting fixed costs onto non-participants, unless inclusion is built in through dedicated finance, membership rules and partnerships with municipalities and social housing. Benefit-sharing can fuel conflict within communities where it privileges some over others, which is why collectively governed trusts, funds and municipalities are a safer channel than payments to individuals. Resistance can be expected from incumbent energy companies that experience energy communities and benefit-sharing as threats to revenue, and from groups that feel excluded from support.
Therefore these programmes need to be designed not only to work technically, but also to consider fairly who has power, who bears the costs and who receives the benefits. Overly generous support can also distort markets or inflate equipment prices, which makes the case for designs tied to cost evidence and reviewed as markets mature. Across all of these, distributional outcomes should be measured instead of assumed, with programmes adjusted where participation or benefits skew away from those the instruments are meant to reach.