Enable

9.1 Involve stakeholders

Decisions that affect communities and electricity users are multiplying across grid planning, infrastructure siting, tariffs and services, and stakeholder involvement that is purely procedural can undermine trust and ultimately fuel resistance. This recommendation calls for involvement that is substantive: participation that is matched to the stakes of each decision, from the provision of information through consultation to co-decision; funded capacity support to address the asymmetries of information, time and resources between affected groups and the institutions of the power sector; early and structured engagement in siting decisions; legally grounded representation of grid users in the governance of the system; independent assurance of the quality of participation processes; and targeted advice that helps people act on the choices that grid modernisation brings.

Why this recommendation matters

Because grid modernisation affects stakeholders across the planning, deployment and operational stages, sustaining its social licence requires that those affected can meaningfully shape it. In planning and deployment, current and future electricity users want to avoid being left behind, with timely access to the grid, sufficient connection capacity, good power quality, reliable service and credible information on grid constraints. These concerns are particularly important to organisations that are seeking to electrify their buildings or industry, and to transport operators planning charging infrastructure and fleet electrification. Siting decisions, in turn, affect the communities along routes and around sites, with concerns ranging from property and landscape impacts to effects on the local economy, environment and, particularly in developing countries, livelihoods. In operation, users of all kinds are affected by the governance of tariffs, connection policy, flexibility procurement, feed-in rules, resilience standards and data protection. Sustaining social licence through a transformation as broad as this requires that those affected can meaningfully shape it. 

Different forms of involvement suit different decisions and groups, although in practice involvement often retains the least intensive forms. Involvement reflects a ladder of intensity, from information and education, through consultation and engagement, to co-design and co-production. Educating consumers can be the right approach to helping households use flexible tariffs.

Informing paired with well-designed incentives can guide investors locating energy-intensive industry or charging infrastructure. For siting decisions, consultation and engagement should be the minimum, with co-design the stronger benchmark. In practice, involvement frequently stays at the bottom of the ladder. Affected groups face asymmetries of information, time, skills, language and resources relative to grid companies, operators and the state. Participation opportunities that assume equal footing can in practice exclude local stakeholders, and marginalised groups can go unrecognised entirely. Such exclusion is experienced as unfairness, and a documented consequence is resistance, protest and litigation. These asymmetries are structural, and therefore require dedicated policy action to be addressed. 

Meaningful involvement improves decision-making and can accelerate delivery of the wider grid modernisation agenda. It brings in knowledge and considerations that would otherwise be missed, from local land use to the practical constraints of flexibility participation, and allows both decision makers and stakeholders to act on better information. It also lays the basis for fairness, since it reveals the needs of different groups at an early stage when design can still respond, and fair treatment builds the support that reduces resistance, protest and legal dispute. Involvement takes time and resources at the outset and tends to repay them by avoiding cost, delay and reputational damage later. Done well, it generally makes grid development quicker, less costly, more legitimate and more robust. 

How to act on this recommendation

Core measures

Implementation considerations

The central tension around stakeholder involvement is between the time and cost of involvement and the pressure for quick decisions. Grid companies, developers and officials may regard extensive participation as time-consuming and costly and prefer to adhere to formal processes, while affected groups may experience formal-only participation as exclusion. Experience shows that a balanced approach with a clear mandate is  a more effective strategy, since insufficient early involvement tends to provoke the resistance that obstructs projects later, at greater expense than the engagement would have cost. The benefits are tangible but not guaranteed, since even well-run involvement cannot eliminate every conflict of interest, and some stakeholders will oppose a project whose costs fall on them however the process is designed. Predictable funding for participation is a recurring difficulty. Financing rules should settle how it is budgeted, whether through budget allocations or through cost-bearing rules for grid companies and project developers. 

Implementing these measures also requires public capacity of its own, which is taken up under recommendation 8.1. Because not all affected groups can participate equally, involvement should proactively be made accessible in location, timing, language and format, with the deliberate inclusion of community groups, small businesses, tenants and informal settlements. Engagement should be aligned with existing permitting and investment processes to limit the consultation fatigue that repeated, uncoordinated exercises impose on the same communities. The incorporation of feedback should be tracked and publicly reported so that people can see how their input shaped outcomes.