Why this recommendation matters
Oversight practices have to evolve along with the power sector. Traditionally, governments and regulatory bodies had to direct and oversee a small number of integrated, often state-owned companies, through instruments such as cost review and periodic tariff decisions. The various trends that are reshaping the power sector require its governance to be updated. Investment, flexibility and innovation, among other activities, are now channelled through a growing number of stakeholders the state does not (fully) own or control, from independent generators and storage operators to new large and distributed consumers and aggregators. At the same time, the grid companies – the natural monopolies at the heart of the sector, many of which are still state-owned – are taking on new responsibilities and should be held accountable for how well they deliver them.
As the power system grows more complex, greater transparency becomes more important for effective oversight and the coordination of a more diverse group of stakeholders. The entities being overseen typically know their own costs, capabilities and constraints better than those overseeing them. That gap widens as actors multiply and new functions emerge and become more complex. Published methodologies, tariff reasoning and performance reporting can help address this, and allow stakeholders other than regulatory bodies to support oversight.
Greater transparency also supports improved coordination in a diversifying sector. Planning authorities, financiers, equipment manufacturers and the owners of the assets whose flexibility the system needs all make decisions that depend on what others will do. Published plans, capacity information and performance records support the alignment of those decisions. Where this information is not widely available, decisions take longer, obligations go unenforced, rules cannot be evaluated adequately against what they were meant to deliver, and stakeholders price the resulting uncertainty into their commitments.
Credible oversight is key to ensuring that grid companies and other stakeholders make long-lived investment decisions that are aligned with system needs. The technical lifetime of grid infrastructure assets runs into decades. Investors across the power sector price the stability of the governance and regulatory regime into the cost of capital. Manufacturers commit production capacity against expected demand. Consumers and providers invest in flexible equipment on the assumption that the rules for participation and payment are clear, robust and enforced. Independent, well-resourced oversight, with clear transparency requirements and performance expectations across grid actors, is what gives these stakeholders the confidence to commit at the pace and scale that grid modernisation requires.
How to act on this recommendation
Stage 1
Establish independent regulatory bodies with clear authority, adequate resources and sufficient technical capacity.
Establish an independent regulator where none exists, and secure its independence, funding and mandate. This includes defining core regulatory functions, strengthening oversight mechanisms and ensuring that regulators can engage with all elements of the emerging system. Match its powers, resources and capability to the task it faces, and adjust them as the task evolves. Strengthen rulemaking through consultation, published reasoning and rights of appeal. Require sectoral authorities and neighbouring jurisdictions to coordinate with the regulator on decisions that affect the grid, and require the methodologies and reasoning behind planning, investment, tariff and operational decisions to be disclosed. Early alignment with planning frameworks is critical to ensure that regulatory approaches reflect future needs.
Stage 2
Move beyond rule-setting to active system management.
Monitor the impact of policies and regulations against predefined indicators so that rules are evaluated and revised as needed. Make tariff-setting transparent, with published methodologies and justification. Establish performance reporting against published targets and benchmarks for regulated companies and for the regulator itself, covering reliability, connection speed, losses, utilisation and decision timeliness. Close coordination with grid company mandates and incentive structures, as set out in recommendation 7.2, becomes essential to ensure that regulatory objectives are effectively translated into action.
Stage 3
Continuously adapt to evolving system conditions and enable independent review.
The regulatory regime should adapt to the changes in the system, including high levels of flexible demand, digitalisation and sector coupling. This requires ongoing regulatory learning and stronger analytical capabilities, and the leveraging of transparency measures, such as public performance reporting and access to operational data, to ensure that regulatory oversight is informed by reliable and timely information. At this stage, regulation plays a key role in maintaining system reliability while enabling innovation. To deepen the legitimacy of the regulatory regime, the largest regulatory and investment decisions should also be made subject to independent review.
Core measures
Implementation considerations
Stakeholder views on stronger oversight tend to divide around its costs and the degree of control it would entail. Grid companies may resist oversight that raises compliance costs or constrains their operational discretion. In some contexts, incumbent actors may also resist reforms that increase market access to others or which redistribute operational responsibilities, particularly where new flexibility providers or aggregators challenge existing business models. Ensuring regulatory independence while maintaining accountability is therefore essential. Governments may face pressure to balance regulatory independence with political priorities, most prominently keeping tariffs affordable for consumers. Investors and private actors typically benefit from stronger and more predictable regulatory frameworks, but may push back if regulatory requirements are perceived as too burdensome. The benefits of greater transparency should be balanced with legitimate concerns around commercially sensitive information, cybersecurity and data privacy. It is important to ensure that disclosure requirements remain proportionate while providing the information needed to reduce uncertainty, monitor system performance, assess compliance and support evidence-based decision-making. At the same time, regulation needs to be able to adapt to rapidly changing circumstances. Balancing predictability with regulatory innovation is a key challenge for regulators.
Equity considerations centre on who ultimately benefits from oversight and who bears its costs. Regulatory decisions directly shape how costs are allocated between users, and poorly designed frameworks can disproportionately affect low-income households or underserved communities. For example, flexibility markets and incentive mechanisms may unintentionally concentrate the benefits among larger or better-resourced actors with greater technical and financial capacity to participate, while smaller consumers continue to bear system costs without equal access to revenues or services. It is therefore important to ensure that regulatory approaches explicitly consider affordability, accessibility and inclusive participation, including through simplified participation pathways and mechanisms that reduce barriers for smaller users and operators, and transparency measures that help reduce information asymmetries. Where appropriate, this can include funding to bring in smaller stakeholders and local authorities that could otherwise not participate, as is explored further in recommendation 9.1.