Objective

Operate

6. Unlock flexibility

The resources that can help operate the power system are multiplying, from tens or hundreds of large plants to millions of assets across supply, storage and demand, owned by utilities, consumers and third parties. Without adequate policy reform, most of their flexibility remains untapped. This is because participation rules exclude them, few of them are exposed to signals they can respond to or are incentivised to respond to, and the services the system needs are not defined or procured in ways they can serve. This objective calls for participation in power system operations to be opened to all capable resources, for assets to be coordinated through prices, tariffs and programmes suited to each system’s structure, and for system services to be defined, quantified and procured on equal terms.

Why this objective matters

Flexibility is the key to delivering a reliable and efficiently utilised modern power system. As solar and wind deployment grows, and demand increases and becomes more variable, the system increasingly needs resources that can adjust when they draw or inject power and how much, so as to avoid having to overinvest in grid infrastructure and back-up resources. At the same time, the pool of resources able to be flexible is expanding: EVs, heat pumps, batteries, rooftop solar, and flexible industrial and commercial demand can shift, curtail or supply power in response to system conditions. In aggregate they represent a resource comparable to conventional generation fleets, except that they are distributed across voltage levels and customer classes. 

This new and growing flexibility potential often remains largely untapped today. The rules that govern participation in power system operations were written for large generators. Consequently, these rules often exclude other resources through prequalification, bid sizes, baselines and penalties that these resources cannot meet. Where aggregation is not adequately governed and regulated, small assets also have no route to participation. Additionally, most assets see no reason to respond: flat tariffs, averaged prices and uniform compensation regimes hide the large differences in what electricity costs to supply at different times and places.

Furthermore, the services the power system needs – such as frequency and voltage control – are often undefined and unquantified, having simply been provided by default by conventional generation. This prevents potential new providers from knowing what is needed and thereby what to invest in, and prevents operators from procuring services from a wider range of resources. 

The cost of leaving flexibility stranded increases as the energy system continues to evolve. If flexibility is underused, variable renewables have to be curtailed while dispatchable plants run in their place, demand peaks have to be met by building new generation and grid capacity is used for only a few tens or hundreds of hours per year. At the same time, the additional connection capacity, system services and investment deferment offered by flexible assets also remain unavailable. Fully unlocking this flexibility instead can shift demand into hours of cheap, clean supply, increase the utilisation of existing grid and generation assets, and allow system services to be sourced more competitively. Flexibility also underpins many other aspects of the toolkit: the alternatives credited in planning under objective 1, the flexible connection terms in objective 4 and the least-cost operation of objective 5 all depend on resources that can be called on and coordinated to operate power systems reliably and cost effectively. 

What’s at stake

Security

Competitiveness

Affordability

What this objective calls for

Achieving this objective requires three related reforms to unlock flexibility, enabling the power system to run at higher utilisation and lower cost. The first widens access: every resource able to provide a service should be able to participate and be rewarded for it. The second coordinates the great bulk of the system’s energy: the volumes consumed, shifted and injected every hour, steered by prices, tariffs and programmes that make responding worthwhile. The third secures what energy coordination alone cannot: the low-volume, high-stakes system services that keep the system stable and restore it when the energy balance is disturbed. Exploring these in turn:

1. Broaden participation. Open participation frameworks to all capable resources on equal terms. This requires recognition of aggregation as a role open to independent parties, participation rules adapted to how demand-side, storage and distributed energy resources behave, flexibility made visible through energy audits, low-friction routes to participation for small assets, and the removal of fiscal and regulatory rules that inadvertently penalise flexible assets. 

2. Coordinate power flows with prices, tariffs and programmes. Ensure assets face signals that make flexible behaviour worthwhile. Depending on the power system’s institutional context, this can include time-variable tariffs and device-level pricing through dynamic prices for large and then retail consumers, direct control programmes and virtual power plants, grid tariffs that reflect cost, and ultimately locational signals.

3. Define and procure system services. Define the services the system needs as standardised products, and then ensure their required volumes are quantified and published and their procurement organised. This covers standardised system-level and local-level services with quantified needs, a common delivery framework, coordinated procurement across transmission and distribution, support where needed, and the services that systems with a high share of inverter-based equipment come to need. 

Policy recommendations

Operate

6.1 Broaden participation 


Flexibility can only be drawn from resources that are allowed to participate. In most systems, the…

Operate

6.2 Coordinate power flows with prices, tariffs and programmes 


Coordinating flexibility requires clear coordination signals. A few hundred plants can be scheduled…

Operate

6.3 Define and procure system services 


System services keep the grid stable and supply secure. Historically they have been provided by…