Enable

8.2 Drive innovation

The power sector has to adopt new technologies, practices and business models at a pace it is not accustomed to. Cultures, rules and cost-recovery arrangements developed around reliability leave grid companies and their regulators with limited room or reward for testing new solutions. Demand-side innovation faces barriers of its own. The pace of innovation on the grid shapes how quickly falling technology costs benefit the system, how securely growing shares of new resources are integrated and whether new entrants can bring their business models to the market. This recommendation calls for innovation to become a routine part of how the grid sector works, with clear opportunities and incentives to experiment, funding that carries solutions from demonstration into routine deployment, and innovation embedded in the revenue regulation of grid companies.

Why this recommendation matters

Reliability has long been the power sector’s defining obligation, resulting in cautious attitudes to innovation. Most grid companies and their regulators have built their cultures and practices around ensuring reliability above all. Among other things, this led grid companies to frequently favour proven equipment and established methods above new solutions. In a landscape that changed slowly, this caution was often the right approach. Generation and grid technologies evolved incrementally, demand in mature systems grew slowly and predictably, and assets designed to last 40 years or more could be planned with confidence. And where new technologies were needed and the surrounding arrangements supported them, the sector did at times adapt, as is evident for example in the increased sophistication of the operation of transmission grids in several power systems.

The slow-changing landscape these cautious attitudes were often appropriate for is now changing quickly. Digitalisation, distributed energy resources, renewables and electrification are challenging fundamental assumptions of power system planning, deployment and operations. While certain new practices have started emerging in front-runner countries, much of the detail of how a future, highly digitalised and more distributed energy system will work is still being developed, from robust anticipatory investment planning practices and large-scale aggregation to the use of artificial intelligence in operations. A risk-averse culture is poorly suited to this pace of change.  

Several factors hold back innovation among grid companies and their regulators, including an operating mindset that treats departure from established practice mainly as a risk, rules that leave little lawful space for testing alternatives, and cost recovery that requires failed experiments to be justified and the savings from successful experiments to be passed on to consumers. Without policy intervention, these patterns will persist. Demand-side innovation in retail, aggregation and industrial electrification faces its own barriers. New business models depend on access to data and markets, which are addressed under objective 6 and recommendation 7.3. Industrial firms also hesitate to experiment with electrified, flexible processes for fear of losing competitiveness.

Policy needs to ensure that the sector can quickly and effectively adopt new capabilities. Technology costs for storage, digital operations and flexibility have fallen quickly and continue to fall. Grid systems able to test and adopt these solutions capture the savings sooner than those that wait for practice to be proven elsewhere. An innovating sector also develops the operational methods that a more variable and more distributed system requires. Openness to new solutions further determines whether new entrants, from technology providers to aggregators, are able to bring their business models to a market at all. The instruments for enabling this are established and tested, and have an implementation track record in a growing set of jurisdictions. 

How to act on this recommendation

Core measures

Implementation considerations

Innovation policy has to balance experimentation against consumer protection and value for money. Sandboxes relax rules and innovation funds spend regulated revenue, so both need defined safeguards, independent evaluation and sunset conditions. Public funding also risks subsidising activity that would have happened anyway, or pilots that do not scale up, so support should be conditional on additionality and paired with routes to deployment. Whether the costs of failed experiments fall on shareholders or on consumers should be settled explicitly through sharing rules. Incumbent grid companies can capture innovation funding and steer it towards their own priorities, so sandboxes, tenders and funds should be open to new entrants and be technology-neutral. Regulators face a related incentive problem: an authority criticised for any failed pilot will permit few, so frameworks should accept a proportion of failures as the cost of learning and judge portfolios rather than individual projects. Incentives alone also achieve little without people able to design, supervise and evaluate experiments, which ties this recommendation to the institutional capacity of recommendation 8.1 and the workforce measures in recommendation 8.3. 

Equity considerations follow the distribution of innovation’s costs and benefits. Consumers fund much of the sector’s innovation through allowances and tariffs, which strengthens the case for published results, verified benefits and shared intellectual property where public money has paid for the learning. Application processes should be proportionate to firm size so that participation costs do not exclude the small innovators the instrument was set up to reach. Communities hosting pilots should share in their benefits, with participation on the consent-based terms in objective 9.