Why this recommendation matters
The bulk system’s task is changing in nature. On the supply side, the system now has to balance residual demand that is shaped by weather, which is more variable and behaves differently from the gross demand of the past, on timescales that conventional scheduling was not designed to follow. On the demand side, electrification is raising and reshaping load, as EVs, heat pumps and large new consumers such as data centres and electrolysers add sharper peaks and further unfamiliar patterns. At the same time, storage adds flows that respond to prices and customer preferences, introducing yet more new grid interaction patterns. In parallel, the physical behaviour of the system is changing: as inverter-based resources displace synchronous generation, the stability properties that were once inherent must increasingly be actively secured, while a more digital, weather-exposed grid carries cyber and extreme-weather risks that were once peripheral to daily operation.
Operating practices calibrated for dispatchable generation and more predictable demand have to evolve. Many operators still tend to maintain large operating margins, schedule only day-ahead and dispatch conservatively.
As operating conditions become more variable, such approaches require more frequent generation redispatch actions, which drive up costs and displace clean generation that could have run. The stability and security once provided by large synchronous machines now also have to be monitored and managed in real time rather than assumed. Conventional operational tools and procedures were not developed for this. Left unaddressed, the result is higher balancing costs, curtailed renewables and a system run cautiously because the operator cannot be sure of its limits.
The solutions are proven and translate into lower costs and a system more capable of integrating variable supply and demand. Dispatch optimisation, better forecasting and shorter scheduling intervals are standard practice in systems that have moved beyond the early phases of renewable integration. Least-cost operation within clearly defined security limits avoids expensive, conservative actions when cheaper flexibility is available. Better forecasting and faster dispatch lower balancing costs and reduce curtailment, reducing both system cost and reliance on imported fuels. Harmonising operation with neighbours allows a wider area to be balanced as one, so less reserve is held in total. System operators that can see and manage its stability in real time can integrate clean supply and new demand at pace.
How to act on this recommendation
Stage 1
Update the foundations of bulk operation and bring scheduling closer to real time.
Policymakers and regulators should define reliability standards that reflect increased variability and deployment of distributed energy resources, and require documented, regularly tested operational protocols covering the full span of operating conditions, including power quality. Transmission system operators should maintain digital grid models to defined standards, since modelling underpins forecasting, dispatch and security assessment alike. Mandate and improve forecasting across demand, renewable output and flexibility availability. Shorten scheduling and dispatch intervals, with schedules updated intraday and closer to delivery. Formulate and test emergency preparedness and response plans for extreme weather, equipment failure, fuel disruption and cyber incidents. These requirements should be matched with adequate capacity building as discussed under objective 8.
Stage 2
Hold operations to least-cost discipline and secure the control systems they depend on.
Policymakers and regulators should require least-cost operation within clearly defined security limits, supported by transparent criteria, reporting and oversight. This helps ensure that operators do not fall back on expensive, conservative actions when cheaper flexibility, storage or grid management options are available. Note that this connects directly to the mobilisation and coordination of flexibility under objective 6. Operators should establish dedicated cybersecurity capabilities for operational technology and grid control systems, from governance and asset inventories to incident detection and response. The two belong together: faster dispatch relying on a broader set of technologies and IT solutions raises the exposure of the systems making the decisions, so cybersecurity should be built in as these capabilities are introduced, in line with the measures in recommendation 7.3.
Stage 3
Operate interconnected systems as one and manage stability in real time.
Harmonise operational protocols across interconnected systems, extending to balancing-area consolidation and imbalance netting so that reserves can be shared. This builds on the cross-geography integration of recommendation 2.3. Operators should also establish real-time frameworks for maintaining stability with a high share of inverters, covering frequency and voltage stability, inertia, fault levels, system strength and protection performance, supported by forward-looking security assessments. These frameworks rest on the observability built under recommendation 5.2 and call on the services procured under recommendation 6.2.
Core measures
Implementation considerations
Modernising bulk system operation is broadly in the interests of operators and consumers alike; frictions are typically about cost, capability and authority rather than direction. Advanced tools and protocols require upfront investment and new skills, and smaller or less well-resourced operators may struggle with both, so regulators need to ensure costs are justified and efficiently allocated and that capacity-building keeps pace. Least-cost operation requirements can meet resistance where they expose discretionary practice to scrutiny, and they only work where the operator has access to the flexibility that cheaper actions depend on. Harmonisation with neighbours raises questions of national operational autonomy, and the objective is to allow interconnected systems to operate predictably together rather than to remove national control. Shorter scheduling intervals and closer-to-real-time dispatch increase the volume and speed of decisions, which raises the operational and cyber risks of the systems making them, so cybersecurity should be built in as these capabilities are introduced rather than added afterwards. Reliability standards written for variability should be tested against the conditions that actually constrain what can be done in practice, since standards that appear robust on annual averages can be inadequate during the narrow windows when the system is most stressed.
Equity considerations centre on uneven capability. Advanced operational systems tend to appear first where infrastructure and finances are strongest, so without deliberate attention their benefits can bypass weaker parts of the grid. Modernisation should be framed around system-wide reliability, including the areas where supply is least dependable, and cost recovery should avoid placing a disproportionate burden on vulnerable consumers while still enabling the investment required.