Why this recommendation matters
Electricity demand growth and the expansion of distributed energy resources are increasingly putting pressure on the traditional grid development model. This can create localised congestion and capacity constraints. Traditional planning approaches default to grid expansion, which is often costly and slow. Many constraints can be addressed more efficiently through targeted solutions such as storage, demand flexibility and the optimised siting of generation and demand. Without systematic evaluation of these alternatives, planning can lead to overinvestment in infrastructure while leaving available flexibility unused.
This recommendation calls for the systematic assessment of alternatives as part of planning and investment decisions. Where planners are required to evaluate storage, demand flexibility, energy efficiency programmes and strategic siting alongside conventional grid upgrades, investment decisions reflect least-cost, system-wide optimisation. It also aligns planning with the direction the system is travelling, in which flexibility and decentralisation play a growing role.
Acting on this brings gains in both cost and speed, and can reach consumers directly. Making better use of existing infrastructure lowers system costs and improves how investment is allocated; avoided reinforcement is expenditure that consumers would otherwise have funded.
Because alternatives can often be deployed faster than grid infrastructure, they also accelerate renewables integration and electrification, shortening the wait for the businesses and households seeking connection.
What is at stake
- Security. Storage, demand response and distributed energy resources can strengthen resilience as well as add capacity. Because they sit close to demand, they give the system local resources to draw on during disruption and reduce reliance on a small number of large assets and long transmission corridors.
- Competitiveness. Alternatives can often be deployed more rapidly than grid infrastructure, which shortens connection times for new supply and demand and helps electrification and renewable projects proceed without waiting for reinforcement.
- Affordability. Meeting a constraint with storage, demand response or efficiency instead of new wires avoids or reduces the capital that consumers would otherwise fund, and makes better use of infrastructure that has already been built.
How to act on this recommendation
Stage 1
Policymakers should establish both the requirement to assess alternatives to grid strengthening within planning and the capability to do it well.
Equip grid companies and regulators with the tools, methods and expertise to evaluate alternatives alongside reinforcement using consistent assumptions. They should incorporate energy efficiency into planning scenarios, since demand not consumed is capacity not required. The falling cost and improving performance of alternatives should also be applied to the goal of achieving universal, high-quality energy access, which should form part of overall grid planning. This work is enabled by the data foundations and planning capability improvements in recommendation 1.1.
Stage 2
The focus shifts to procurement and integration.
Regulators should put in place procurement mechanisms and cost recovery frameworks that allow alternatives such as demand response, storage and distributed energy resources to substitute for reinforcement where they are cost-effective. They should support well-sited options such as community-scale storage near constrained substations. Mechanisms should automatically include systematic evaluation and implementation of alternatives, so that they are considered as a matter of course rather than case by case. This relies strongly on the operational capabilities under objectives 5 and 6, and on the grid codes and connection terms under objective 4, which together set the framework for the reliable activation of flexibility and other system services.
Core measures
Implementation considerations
The interests of parties in the power system as regards grid alternatives are mostly aligned, but can conflict with utility incentives. System operators, developers and consumers seeking lower costs all benefit from alternatives being considered. The exception is the grid company itself: where regulation rewards capital expenditure through a return on the asset base, grid companies have a financial reason to prefer reinforcement over alternatives that may sit on others’ balance sheets. Addressing this misalignment, through the incentive and cost recovery reforms of objective 7, is the single most important implementation task. Providers of flexibility, storage and efficiency services face other barriers: without clear procurement rules and access to grid data, they cannot identify or compete for opportunities. Transparent methodologies, appropriate incentives and well-defined procurement frameworks are therefore essential.
Equity considerations arise because alternatives are more readily deployed in some locations than others. Storage, demand flexibility and distributed energy resources tend to be more available in areas with higher-income end users or stronger economic activity, so the cost savings they unlock can accrue unevenly across regions and customer groups. Planning frameworks should account for diverse system conditions, including areas that currently have few distributed energy resources, and cost allocation arrangements should ensure that the savings from avoided investment are shared fairly rather than captured only where alternatives happen to be plentiful. Inclusive participation mechanisms and targeted support help ensure that alternatives to grid reinforcement contribute both to efficient operation and to a more equitable distribution of their benefits.