How to Use

Challenge brief: tackling connection queues

About the challenge briefs. Each challenge brief takes a problem that many power systems face and brings together the parts of the toolkit that help address it. The relevant recommendations and measures come from several objectives, since most challenges cut across planning, deployment, operation and the enabling environment. Use the brief as a route into the toolkit, then follow the links to the recommendations and measures for the full detail. 

The challenge

The number and size of requests to connect to the grid have grown sharply, and so has the time it takes to get connected. At transmission level, queues are filled with utility-scale solar, wind and battery storage, joined increasingly by large loads such as data centres and electrified industry. At distribution level, rooftop solar, home batteries and above all EV charging and heat pumps face increasingly long waiting times as well. In many systems, connecting a project now takes longer than building it. 

Part of the volume is speculative. Applications are typically cheap to lodge and carry few obligations, so developers apply early, in several locations, and hold positions they may never use. Where reforms have required applicants to show that their projects are ready to proceed and to commit funds, queues have shrunk substantially. 

The processes behind the queues were designed for a small number of large, predictable connections. Assessment is often manual, applications are handled on a first-come, first-served basis, and connections are granted as firm rights sized for worst-case conditions that rarely occur. Grid capacity is therefore reserved for projects that may not proceed, while viable projects wait for reinforcement that can take five to fifteen years to plan, permit and build. 

The consequences reach well beyond the grid. Delays raise financing costs and can undermine the business case for new projects, so renewables, storage and electrification stall and some investment goes elsewhere or reverts to fossil-fuel equipment. Because grid companies and grid infrastructure move more slowly than the projects seeking connection, many of the measures that address queues take years to take effect once a queue has become visible. Acting before queues build up tends to cost less and reduce or avoid delays. 

How the toolkit helps

The toolkit points to five principles for action. The first three can shorten queues within a few years. The last two address the causes, so that queues do not build up again as supply and demand keep growing. 

Quick-acting reforms 

Keep the queue to viable projects. Minimum application requirements, such as evidence of site control, technical data and a financial commitment, keep speculative applications out. Milestone-based queue management removes projects that stall. Prioritising applications by readiness and system value, in place of the order in which they arrived, lets viable, system-friendly projects move ahead. Digital applications, simplified routes for small assets and tiered, batched connection studies speed up processing. Draws on recommendation 4.2 streamline connection management. 

Offer faster access in return for flexibility. Projects willing to accept occasional curtailment, connect in phases, share a connection point or operate within limits that vary with grid conditions can be connected sooner, or at lower cost, than under firm terms. Large loads can gain faster access in exchange for binding flexibility commitments. Published hosting capacity maps and locational signals in connection charges reward projects that choose to site where the grid has room. Draws on recommendations 4.2 streamline connection management, and 4.3 reward flexibility with better connection terms. 

Use the capacity the grid already has. Dynamic ratings, grid-enhancing technologies and the reconductoring of existing lines release capacity in months to a few years. Better visibility of the distribution grid allows connections to be assessed against actual conditions in place of worst-case assumptions. Over time, curative congestion management lets operators run the grid closer to its limits. Draws on recommendations 5.2 activate the distribution layer, and 5.3 optimise the use of existing infrastructure. 

Structural reforms 

Plan and build ahead of the queue. Requiring developers of large loads to share their plans with grid planners, coordinating transmission and distribution planning, and investing ahead of credible need give the grid time to keep pace with new supply and demand. Assessing alternatives to reinforcement, such as storage and flexible demand, can deliver capacity sooner. Long-term project pipelines help equipment manufacturers expand capacity, so approved projects are not held up by supply chains. Draws on recommendations 1.1 modernise planning methodologies, 1.2 enable anticipatory investment, 1.3 leverage alternatives to reinforcement, and 3.3 strengthen supply chains. 

Reward grid companies for connecting users. Where grid companies earn returns mainly on capital spending, they have little reason to choose quicker, cheaper solutions or to prioritise connection speed. Performance-based regulation can reward faster connections and released capacity, while treating capital and operating expenditure equally makes flexibility and operational solutions commercially attractive. Published performance against connection targets lets regulators and users hold grid companies to account. Draws on recommendations 7.1 strengthen oversight and transparency, and 7.2 revise grid company governance. 

Where to start

The measures below are examples of where action on connection queues typically begins, placed by domain and by stage of grid modernisation. The number after each measure is the recommendation it belongs to. Finding your starting point explains how to identify your system’s stage, and develop a reform roadmap explains how to sequence measures from there. 

 

Stage 1: Foundation Stage 2: Acceleration Stage 3: Transformation 
Plan Mandate large-load data sharing (1.1) 
Build utility and regulator capability to evaluate alternatives (1.3) 
Coordinate planning between transmission and distribution (1.1) 
Establish risk-sharing mechanisms for anticipatory investments (1.2) 
Mandate systematic evaluation and implementation of alternatives (1.3) 
Deploy Set minimum application requirements (4.2) 
Remove non-viable projects from connection queues (4.2) 
Introduce flexible connection agreements (4.3) 
Establish differentiated connection terms for large loads (4.3) 
Develop, publish and integrate hosting capacity maps (4.2) 
Prioritise connection applications (4.2) 
Develop a framework for phased connection agreements (4.3) 
Use locational signals and spatial planning to steer new connections (4.3) 
Move to dynamic, operational hosting capacity (4.2) 
Set binding maximum connection timelines and accountability mechanisms (4.2) 
Introduce dynamic operating envelopes (4.3) 
Operate Mandate a distributed energy resource registry (5.2) 
Require dynamic ratings and dynamic operational limits (5.3) 
Mandate expanded low-voltage observability and control (5.2) 
Mandate or incentivise grid-enhancing technologies (5.3) 
Upgrade existing lines through reconductoring and uprating (5.3) 
Establish the DSO as an active system operator (5.2) 
Adopt curative congestion management (5.3) 
Enable Define grid company transition mandates (7.2) Establish performance reporting against published targets (7.1) 
Introduce output- and performance-based revenue regulation (7.2) 
Adopt TOTEX cost treatment (7.2) 

What to keep in mind

Stricter entry requirements and deposits clear speculative applications, but they can also exclude smaller developers, municipal actors and community projects that are serious but less well capitalised. Requirements proportionate to project size, staged deposits and published standard terms for flexible connections help keep access open to them. How the cost of upgrades triggered by new connections is shared between the connecting party and other grid users shapes both who pays and where projects locate, and should be settled openly as a policy decision. Firm-capacity users and holders of existing queue positions may see reforms as a loss, so transparent criteria and transition arrangements matter for investor confidence. 

 

Good practices and further reading

Examples of good practice are can be found on the relevant measure pages, including those on queue reform, flexible connection agreements and hosting capacity maps. Additional key resources are listed below:

 

Continue reading

Continue through the guide with the next article.

Challenge brief: integrating data centres